|
SUBSECTION:
|
SECTION
I: TRAFFICKING
|
|
|
TITLE
|
AUTHOR/AFFILIATION
|
DATE
|
SOURCE
|
|
1a
|
The
'White Slavery' Panic
|
Joanne
McNeil
|
April
2008
|
Reason
Magazine
|
|
1b
|
The
Vice Trust: A
Reinterpretation of the
White Slavery Scare in the
United States, 1907-1917
|
Mara
Keire
|
Fall
2001
|
Journal
of Social History -
Volume 35, Number 1, pp. 5-41
|
|
1c
|
Time
to Challenge the Anti-
Prostitution Lobby
|
Alison
Murray
|
1994
(approx)
|
Essays
on Trafficking
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 1 a-c
|
History
of Prostitution as Trafficking
Issue- How the ‘moral panic’
over the ‘white slave trade’
of the late 19th and early
20th century became the moral
and social panic over sex
trafficking of the
present. Article 1A is
especially important to
explain the lies and false
premises that triggered the
hysteria over 100 years ago,
which are still employed today
to continue the panic of the
so called sex slave trade.
|
|
2
|
Data
and Research on Human
Trafficking: Bibliography of
Research-Based Literature
|
ELŻBIETA
M. GOŹDZIAK, PH.D. AND
MICAH
N. BUMP, M.A.
|
October
2008
|
Institute
for the Study of International
Migration, Walsh School of
Foreign Service, Georgetown
University
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 2
|
This
report was prepared for Karen
J. Bachar, Ph.D. Social
Science Analyst and Violence
and Victimization Research
Division, Office of Research
and Evaluation National
Institute of Justice
and U.S. Department of Justice
|
|
3
|
The
Left, The Right and the
Prostitute: The Making of
the U.S. Anti Trafficking in
Persons Policy
|
Jacqueline
Berman
|
Spring
2006
|
Tulane
Journal of International and
Comparative Law
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 3
|
A
very important examination of
the anti trafficking
propaganda that influences the
policy under which so many
men, women and children are
harmed.
|
|
4a
|
The Growing
Moral Panic Over Prostitution
and Sex Trafficking
|
Prof. Ronald
Weitzer
|
Sept/Oct
2005
|
The
Criminologist/ American Society
of Criminology:
Vol. 30 No.5
|
|
4b
|
Flawed
Theory and Method of Studies
in Prostitution
|
Prof.
Ronald Weitzer
|
July 2005
|
Violence
Against Women, Vol. 11, No. 7
Sage Publications
|
|
4c
|
Prostitution
Harms Women Even if Indoors:
Reply to Weitzer
|
Melissa
Farley
|
July 2005
|
Violence
Against Women, Vol. 11, No. 7
Sage Publications
|
|
4d
|
Sociology
of Sex Work
|
Prof.
Ronald Weitzer
|
2009
|
Annual
Review of Sociology
|
|
4e
|
The
Social Construction of Sex
Trafficking: Ideology
and Institutionalization
of a Moral Crusade
|
Prof.
Ronald Weitzer
|
Summer
2007
|
Politics
and Society/SAGE publications
|
|
4f
|
Mythology
of Prostitution: Advocacy
Research and Public Policy
|
Prof.
Ronald Weitzer
|
Feb. 2010
|
Sex Res
Soc Policy online
|
|
4g
|
Prostitution:
Facts and Fictions
|
Prof.
Ronald Weitzer
|
Fall 2007
|
American
Sociological Association Vol.
6, no 4, pp 28-33
|
|
4h
|
Rehashing
Tired Claims About
Prostitution
|
Prof.
Ronald Weitzer
|
July 2005
|
Violence
Against Women, Vol. 11, No. 7
Sage Publications
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 4a-h
|
THIS
SUBSECTION IS A MUST READ-
both Prof. Weitzer’s articles
and the ‘response’ to his
articles by Melissa Farley. Prof.
Weitzer is with the George
Washington University,
Department of Sociology. His current research is on
legal prostitution systems.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
5a
|
Human
Trafficking Evokes Outrage,
Little Evidence
|
Jerry Markon
|
Sept. 23,
2007
|
The
Washington Post
|
|
5b
|
Sex
Trafficking: The
Abolitionist Fallacy
|
Ann
Jordan
|
March
2009
|
Foreign
Policy in Focus
|
|
5c
|
The
Crusade Against Sex
Trafficking
|
Noy
Thrupkaew
|
Sept.
16, 2009
|
The
Nation Institute
|
|
5d
|
Beyond
Rescue/ part two of a 2 part
series
|
Noy
Thrupkaew
|
Oct
8, 2009
|
The
Nation Institute
|
|
5e
|
Border
Thinking on Migration,
Trafficking and Commercial
Sex: How ‘Rescue’ from
trafficking yet again means
police detention
|
Laura
Agustin
|
July
20, 2010
|
Laura
is a well known and highly
respected researcher on migrant
labor and trafficking
|
|
5f
|
Stop
this illicit trade in bullshit
stories
|
Brendan
O’Neill
|
Mar
18, 2010
|
Spiked-
online
|
|
5g
|
Prostitution
and trafficking- the anatomy
of a moral panic
|
Nick
Davies
|
October
20, 2009
|
The
Guardian (UK)
|
|
5h
|
Md.
police seek tougher laws to
combat human trafficking
|
Dan
Morse
|
March
3, 2010
|
The
Washington Post
|
|
5i
|
Oversexed
|
Debbie
Nathan
|
Aug
11, 2005
|
The
Nation
|
|
5j
|
Inquiry
fails to find single
trafficker who forced anybody
into prostitution
|
Nick
Davies
|
October
20, 2009
|
id #000000;" valign="top">
The
Guardian (UK)
|
|
5k
|
New
State Department Human
Trafficking Estimate: 12.3
Million [and
we found out the moon IS
made of green cheese!!!!nj]
|
unknown
author/ UTTER BS!!!!!
|
June
18, 2010
|
www.womensnews.org/story/prostitution-and-trafficking/100615/sex-traffic-rises-along-scramble-solutions
|
|
5L
|
Recommended
Principles and Guidelines on
Human Rights and Human
Trafficking
|
United
Nations
|
(?)
2002
|
Office
of the High Commissioner for
Human Rights
|
|
5m
|
Anti-
Trafficking and the Production
of the Nation: Female
Migrants, Prostitution and
State Control
|
Kerwin
Kaye
|
Approx.
2004
|
New
York University
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 5 a-m
|
The
above subsection has a number
of very important articles-
including one (5a) from the
Washington Post (2007)
which states that despite the
best efforts of all the anti-
trafficking organizations
which receive millions of
government dollars, actual
trafficked victims are just
not being found...
|
|
|
|
|
6
|
Perfect
Victims and Real Survivors:
The
Iconic Victim in Domestic Human
Trafficking Law
|
JAYASHRI
SRIKANTIAH
Associate
Professor of Law and Director,
Immigrants’ Rights Clinic,
Stanford Law Sch ool
|
Feb.
2007
|
Boston
University Law Review
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 6
|
....The
abolitionist view espoused by
the Bush administration is
that sex work is inherently
non-consensual. Victims of sex
trafficking are passive as to
their exploitation because the
nature of sex work is such
that consent is impossible.
Focus
on iconic victims who are
completely helpless victims of
sex trafficking leaves little
room for victims of
trafficking for forced
labor...
|
|
7
|
Redefining
Prostitution as Sex Work on
the International Agenda
|
Jo
Bindman, Anti- Slavery
International
Jo
Doezema, Network of Sex Work
Projects
|
June
1997
|
Anti-
Slavery International
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 7
|
Until
sex work is recognized as
work, and it is understood
that there are many men, women
and transgendered persons who
choose to engage in sex work-
for whatever reason, those who
are truly victims of coercion
and violence do not have a
chance to be acknowledged as
such. Resources are squandered
by law enforcement agencies
going after everyone involved
in prostitution rather than
listening to the sex workers
who are most likely to know
who is and isn’t a victim and
who is trafficking
underage persons and forcing
anyone into sex slavery (which
is much different than
prostitution)
|
|
8
|
Sex,
slaves and citizens: the
politics of
anti-trafficking
|
Bridget
Anderson and Rutvica
Andrijasevic
|
Winter
2008
|
Soundings,
Winter, Issue 40
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 8
|
“Trafficking
is in the news. Thousands of
individuals, hundreds of
groups, dozens of newspapers
are determined to stamp it
out. This focus on trafficking
consistently reflects and
reinforces deep public concern
about prostitution/sex work..
to challenge the expression...
is akin to saying that one
endorses slavery or is against
motherhood and apple pie...
But we believe it is necessary
to tread the line of
challenging motherhood and
apple pie while not endorsing
slavery, because the moral
panic over trafficking is
diverting attention from the
structural causes of the abuse
of migrant workers...”
|
|
9
|
Kicking
Down the Door: The Use of
Raids to Fight Trafficking in
Persons
|
Sex
Workers Project 2009
|
#000000;" valign="top">
(?)
2009
|
Sex
Workers Project
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 9
|
“These
raids are ugly and horrible.
They…bang on the door, they
break the door, they come in
with the guns out! In the
beginning, it’s frightening
and upsetting. [Law
enforcement] could do
anything, you don’t know what
they are going to do. … It’s
really horrible, sometimes if
they are very angry, they
don’t let you get dressed.
They take you in your work
clothes. … One never lets go
of the fear. Being afraid
never goes away. They provoke
that.” Celia, arrested seven
timese without being screened
for trafficking
|
|
10
|
Human
Trafficking: Better Data,
Strategy and Reporting Needed
to Enhance US Anti-trafficking
Efforts
|
United
States Government
Accountability Office
|
July
2006
|
Report
to the Chairman, Committee on
the Judiciary and the Chairman,
Committee on International
Relations, House of
Representatives
|
|
10 B
|
US
GOVERNMENT REPORT: 2011 Report:
Characteristics of Suspected
Human Trafficking Incidents-
2008- 2010
|
|
11
|
The
Politics of Human Trafficking
|
Neil
Howard and Mumatz Lalani
|
April
2008
|
St.
Anthony’s International
Review, Volume 4, Number
1,
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 11
|
“Though
much contemporary coverage
depicts human trafficking as a
terrifying new phenomenon
situated within very original
debates as to how it should be
stopped, Kemala Kempadoo,
amongst others, has detailed a
historical context and
discursive tradition that
dates back over a century. In
late nineteenth century Europe
and North America, she
explains,
the increasing social and
physical mobility of
unaccompanied women provoked a
conservative moralistic
Victorian outcry against what
was seen as a threat to the
very fabric of society.”
|
|
12
|
Prostitution
Policies and Sex Trafficking:
Assessing the use of
prostitution based policies as
tools for combating sex
trafficking
|
Victoria
Hayes
|
Fall
2008
|
Kentlaw.edu
final paper
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 12
|
This
paper explores the
relationship between
prostitution and sex
trafficking, examining the use
of prostitution-based policies
as a tool for combating sex trafficking and assessing the
value of focusing on these
prostitution-based policies in
the battle against sex
trafficking. The first section
describes the international
definition of trafficking in
human beings and its position
on regulating prostitution.
The second section outlines
the four general approaches to
prostitution legislation:
complete criminalization,
partial decriminalization,
decriminalization, and
legalization
|
|
13
|
Prostitution,
Sex Work and Violence:
Discursive
and Political Contexts for
Five
Texts on Paid Sex, 1987–2001
|
Svati
P. Shah
|
November
2004
|
Gender
& History, Vol.16 No.3, pp.
794–812.
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 13
|
“Feminist
debates on prostitution are
critically informed and, in
some instances, shaped by
their engagements with
violence in gendered
exploitation. The physical and
symbolic practices of violence
experienced by women selling
sexual services together
comprise an abiding feature of
arguments against prostitution
altogether, and one of the
main points of
contention
between prostitution
abolitionists, and advocates
of the rights of
prostitutes/sex workers. “
|
|
14
|
Behind
Closed Doors: An Analysis of
Indoor Sex Work in New York
City
|
Juhu
Thukral, Esq.,
Melissa Ditmore, Ph.D., and
Alexandra Murphy
|
(?)
2005
|
Sex
Workers Project at the Urban
Justice Center
|
|
Comments/
Notes Subsection 14
|
“In
recent years, the United
States government has turned
its attention to the issue of
human trafficking with renewed
vigor. This focus has
culminated in national
legislation, the Trafficking
Victims Protect Act (TVPA) of
2000.9 The TVPA aims to
“combat trafficking in
persons, a contemporary
manifestation of slavery whose
victims are predominantly
women and children, to ensure
just and effective punishment
of traffickers, and to protect
their victims.”
|
